Egg Wars – Father vs. Son

Avian flu and the rising cost of feed have created problems for the egg industry. At a farm in Aichi Prefecture, a father and son clash over methods. The father wants to continue raising chickens in cages, but the son wants to raise birds cage free, which is a costlier approach. Through this film, the son hopes to spark a dialogue between them. What feelings have they not been able to express to each other? This is a story of a family divided over eggs. Can they reach a resolution?

Transcript

00:04

Stories about people, stories about life.

00:07

Hometown Stories.

00:22

At the center of today's story - eggs.

00:29

Rising feed costs and a surge in avian flu cases have sent egg prices soaring in Japan.

00:36

Faced with these unprecedented challenges, a father and son are at odds over farming methods.

00:43

The father is an advocate of intensive farming using battery cages - a method he has relied on for years.

00:52

I raise as many as I can.

00:55

It was crucial for me to produce eggs
as cheaply as possible.

01:01

But his son has begun taking a more costly approach.

01:07

They can roam around freely.
Free in every aspect.

01:12

My eggs are pricier at 1 dollar a piece,

01:14

but that fits with the changing times.

01:18

This has led to some conflicts.

01:20

- You're not going to use my method?
- I'm not.

01:24

I'm forging my own path.
I'm not your mini-me or your slave.

01:29

Get off your high horse.

01:34

A family divided over eggs.

01:36

Will they reach a resolution?

01:46

Our story is set in a poultry farm in Aichi Prefecture.

01:56

This small farm has been around for half a century.

02:04

The 30,000 or so chickens here are reared in battery cages,

02:08

with two birds sharing a space just 20 centimeters wide.

02:17

About 90% of Japan's eggs are produced using cheap and intensive farming methods like this.

02:29

Miyamoto Kentaro has been working on this farm for over a decade.

02:33

It was started by his father.

02:39

I used to be a sales rep
for a pharmaceutical company.

02:43

Then in 2011, there was an outbreak
of avian flu in a nearby town.

02:47

That's when I began helping my dad.

02:50

I eventually got
fully involved in poultry farming.

02:59

Then, a few years ago, Kentaro built a separate coop on the farm and began to try a different method.

03:16

They come rushing to me when
I walk into the coop with their feed.

03:21

That makes me happy.

03:27

He is raising his chickens cage-free.

03:29

That's less stressful for the birds and takes their welfare into account.

03:41

I didn't know they enjoyed dust baths.

03:43

I learned that they bathe
in the sand to get rid of fleas.

03:58

She got upset.

04:01

They can lay eggs where they want.

04:03

And roam around.
They're free in every respect.

04:10

Rearing cage-free poultry requires more space.

04:14

This coop can house around 800 chickens.

04:22

That is why cage-free eggs tend to be more expensive.

04:29

Eggs in Japan are known
for being inexpensive,

04:32

but I think the prices
I charge are fair.

04:37

They shouldn't be super cheap to buy.

04:44

Someday, Kentaro hopes to take over his father's poultry farm and convert it into an entirely cage-free operation.

05:01

Along with his wife and kids, Kentaro visits his parents every Friday.

05:07

Something has been on his mind.

05:12

Hey there.

05:16

His father Yoshio had just gotten home.

05:19

He has been a poultry farmer for 50 years.

05:26

Yoshio and Kentaro have barely talked about the future of the farm.

05:37

Do you want to discuss it with him?

05:40

I'd always wanted to in the past.

05:43

But since he's been in this line
of work for 50 years,

05:49

he's not open to ideas from
someone he thinks is less experienced.

05:55

We need to have
those discussions soon.

06:08

Kentaro agreed to being filmed in order to help create a channel for communication.

06:22

Yoshio produced eggs from caged chickens since the beginning.

06:30

Ideally, I want him to keep running
things like this once he takes over.

06:35

He says he wants
to take a cage-free approach.

06:40

I have no idea how he plans
to go about that.

06:48

Yoshio lost his father at a young age.

06:51

After graduating from high school, he taught himself to raise chickens to support his family.

06:58

He started off with 100 birds and the scale of his operations continued to grow over the years.

07:04

Yoshio became the father of four children.

07:08

I lost my right hand as I was
preparing feed with heavy machinery.

07:13

I was worried about working
with just one arm,

07:21

but my willpower kept me going.

07:25

I was only able to come
this far thanks to the chickens.

07:30

I'm so grateful to them.

07:34

Yoshio felt that the only way he could support his family was through intensive farming,

07:40

in response to the demand for cheap eggs.

07:44

It was crucial for me to produce eggs
as cheaply as possible.

07:53

If you can't commit to that,

07:56

your business won't stand a chance.

08:04

Have you discussed
the farm with Kentaro?

08:07

Not really.

08:10

I don't like lecturing
my son and criticizing his methods.

08:17

I'd rather have him observe
how I work and judge for himself.

08:41

Yoshio and Kentaro are visiting their accountant's office to see how the business is doing.

08:52

Feed costs are up 20%
over last year.

08:58

Net sales are down by
about 13,000 dollars.

09:02

The major reason is that sales
are down for cage-raised eggs.

09:11

However, things are looking up for Kentaro's cage-free operation.

09:17

Are these figures
for cage-free eggs correct?

09:24

Revenue for cage-free eggs is
up 164% compared to last year.

09:31

I think it's a result
of your sales initiatives.

09:37

It's quite impressive.

09:41

Demand has been shifting from
mass-production to higher quality.

09:47

Kentaro is on the right track,
selling quality eggs at a higher price.

09:55

I think this approach
can help boost profits.

10:08

Kentaro has been pouring his energy into direct sales, emphasizing the merits of cage-free eggs.

10:15

That's contributed to his success.

10:20

What's the best way to prepare them?

10:23

I suggest cooking them
sunny side up with a runny yolk.

10:33

They're on the pricier side,

10:36

but I prefer buying eggs
from stress-free chickens.

10:41

I also want my child to be
conscious about these things.

10:50

My dad's approach may have
been right before, but not anymore.

10:55

Times are changing.

11:05

Three weeks have passed since they spoke to their accountant.

11:12

They're here.

11:18

Yoshio has decided to take a big step.

11:27

For the first time this year, he's bought more chicks, 7,000.

11:32

That's more than in years past.

11:37

Avian flu outbreaks have led to a shortage of eggs and a surge in prices.

11:42

Yoshio saw this as a potential business opportunity.

11:52

We need large quantities
for efficient production.

11:57

So we need to
raise high-quality chickens.

12:06

You want Kentaro to see you in action?

12:09

Yes, I do.
Did he say anything?

12:14

I suggested...

12:16

that he come here to see the chicks,

12:23

but he said he was busy.

12:29

For Kentaro, bringing in more chicks is a signal that his father intends to continue a battery-cage operation.

12:42

I'm a cage-free farmer.
I don't like seeing the chickens in cages.

12:49

I want to look after my family,
but my dad's methods are unsustainable.

12:55

That means that I have to
focus on my own business approach.

13:04

Caught in the crossfire between father and son is Kentaro's mother, Yukiko.

13:11

Although she's in poor health, she still works on the farm.

13:22

I have to listen to both sides,
so I'm stuck in the middle.

13:26

My husband vents to me,
and so does my son.

13:32

Being the intermediary
is so frustrating.

13:37

Kentaro needs to talk to his dad
with more sensitivity.

13:46

I want them to have
peaceful discussions.

13:58

I'm here.

14:03

Kentaro was seeking an opportunity to broach the subject.

14:08

It arrives unexpectedly.

14:13

The pudding is so rich.

14:22

Kentaro is supplying eggs to a renowned pâtissier in a faraway town.

14:27

His father shares his opinion.

14:32

Delivering to a shop so far away
is a waste of time and money.

14:39

He's a famous pâtissier.
It's good for publicity.

14:51

It beats sitting here and
grumbling about poor sales.

14:58

It's a tough decision...

15:04

It's not tough at all.

15:06

I know how to produce eggs,
but not how to sell or promote them.

15:11

It's not Yoshio's forte.

15:13

Well it's my forte.

15:18

- You're not going to use my method?
- I'm not.

15:23

It's not right that you
impose your views on me.

15:32

It feels like everything
I've done is being dismissed.

15:37

He said that your approach
was fine until now,

15:41

but from here on,
it will be tough to uphold.

15:52

You have your ways.

15:55

I'm forging my own path.
You need to respect that.

15:59

I'm not your mini-me or your slave.

16:06

There was a reason why Kentaro wanted to take over the business soon.

16:13

Mom is on the verge of collapsing.

16:18

She needs to take it easy.

16:22

I'm so worried that she'll get sick.
She needs to stop working.

16:28

- I do treat her well.
- You don't.

16:34

It's just hard for her
that we're fighting.

16:37

That's not true.
That's between you two.

16:40

Your marital problems are
seeping into our relationship too.

16:45

Get off your high horse.

16:52

You get so emotional.

16:54

You're putting yourself on
a pedestal and talking down to me.

17:04

Mom will collapse.
Let's go home.

17:11

Bye-bye.

17:30

I apologize for that.

17:34

How do you feel
about that discussion?

17:37

That wasn't a discussion.

17:38

Both of us just let out
a lot of pent-up feelings.

17:43

Kentaro was able to speak frankly.
I think that's an improvement.

17:50

We're getting old, so I think
things will eventually go his way.

18:00

I'm already 70,
so I guess that's inevitable.

18:09

He's making valid points, but...

18:17

I still want to
keep doing things my way.

18:21

Just a while longer.

18:47

Two weeks later.

18:52

Kentaro is visiting a local business consultant.

19:01

We've been locking horns,
shooting down each other's ideas.

19:04

These disagreements are
keeping us from moving forward.

19:09

He hopes to resolve the issues with his father.

19:15

I want us to reach an understanding
and accept each other's reasoning.

19:23

That's why I came to you.

19:29

The consultant had a question about Kentaro's father.

19:36

Did he lose his hand
before he began farming?

19:39

No, it was while he was working.

19:41

He probably had to come up with
his own unique solutions to work.

19:46

Because of that, I believe
your father has strong attachments

19:53

to his farming methods, equipment,
and business achievements.

19:57

If it weren't for him, us four kids
couldn't have gone to university.

20:07

It's so impressive that
he can work with just one hand.

20:12

We all went to private universities.

20:18

I'm sure it cost a lot of money.

20:20

It's amazing he could afford that.

20:30

Kentaro decides to give talking to his father another go.

20:51

This time, the consultant will be present.

21:05

Kentaro and his father will share their views on the future of the farm.

21:15

I need to train my successors.

21:18

Drops in revenue might
be another potential issue.

21:28

Kentaro has decided to listen attentively to his father.

21:37

Suddenly, Yoshio opens up.

21:45

I struggled after losing my hand,

21:50

but it also led me to feel gratitude.

21:55

I feel it much more
than the ordinary person.

22:03

That's how it is with me.

22:08

I want to express
my gratitude to my wife,

22:14

and everyone in my life.

22:26

Kentaro had never heard his father talk like this before.

22:32

Our opinions may differ
on the small details,

22:36

but looking at the bigger picture,
I think we're on the same page.

22:56

They've decided to hold regular monthly
father-son discussions.

23:19

They still lock horns sometimes.

23:25

You should bring in more chickens.

23:28

That'll compromise the quality.

23:31

Farming isn't a hobby.

23:33

Well, my set-up
is bringing in profits.

23:40

I'll have rice with a raw egg.

23:44

A simple dish.

23:45

I'll use one of Kentaro's eggs.

23:53

How is it?

23:56

Delicious.

24:03

It's natural for us to think differently.

24:05

We grew up in different times
and different environments.

24:10

It would be strange
if our perspectives were identical.

24:18

It's not unusual to have quarrels
around business succession.

24:26

That's how to reach better outcomes
than your predecessor.

24:34

I may be hard headed,
but so is my son.

24:38

I'm not hard headed.
Just unwavering.