Into the Gray: Redemption of an Ex-Yakuza

Morohashi Yoshitomo is a criminal defense lawyer based in downtown Tokyo. But he was once a yakuza. He believes second chances start in the space between black and white, between right and wrong.

Transcript

00:07

Morohashi Yoshitomo has fought his way back from rock bottom.

00:19

The 47-year-old is a lawyer.

00:27

His movement could be better.

00:33

But he once lived on the other side of the law.

00:44

Morohashi used to be a yakuza.

00:54

Now, he helps others who have also had their day of reckoning.

01:00

People don't think good of me, as a former gangster.

01:06

Morohashi is like a shepherd.

01:13

I want to protect those who have become disadvantaged. They have suffered, and lived hard lives.

01:25

Japanese society can be unforgiving.

01:29

And Morohashi believes second chances start in the space between black and white...

01:35

between right and wrong.

01:52

Morohashi's office sits in a corner of Asakusa, downtown Tokyo.

02:08

Thanks for coming so early.

02:14

I'm happy to have my own office.

02:24

I received an early morning call, asking for a consultation.

02:37

Morohashi mostly handles criminal cases.

02:43

His client today needs advice before heading to the police for questioning.

02:51

They want to ask me about marijuana, so I thought I should see a lawyer.

03:02

Possessing marijuana is illegal in Japan.

03:05

And Morohashi's client has been charged with the crime before.

03:16

This kind of thing should be dealt with quickly.

03:21

Even if the outcome is bad, you'll at least be able to start over sooner.

03:31

Morohashi's client visits the police station, as requested.

03:36

And Morohashi parks nearby.

03:40

Good morning. Thank you for today.

03:43

I'll stay here.

03:49

I'm nervous.

03:51

Relax. Now go.

03:56

Thanks.

04:08

Morohashi waits for three hours.

04:19

I'm back.

04:24

It went OK. I feel relieved.

04:32

Thank you for waiting a long time.

04:40

You must be tired.

04:42

If the police call me again, can I call you?

04:48

Of course, please get in touch.

04:54

No matter what, Morohashi always tries to show understanding.

05:03

Japan is known around the world as a safe country.

05:09

But at the same time, statistics suggest recidivism - when convicts reoffend - is a stubborn problem.

05:18

In 2022, police arrested almost 170,000 people.

05:22

About 48 percent already had criminal records.

05:27

Social rehabilitation is seen as vital for bringing the rate down.

05:42

You know, the shift from black to white isn't always so sudden.

05:50

It can be better to first go from black to gray.

06:02

This is Morohashi's driver, Sampei Hirokatsu.

06:07

Sampei also belonged to the yakuza.

06:10

He left six years ago with seven criminal convictions including bodily harm and attempted fraud.

06:18

But he's a gangster no more.

06:20

And that means he can open a bank account -

06:23

something ex-yakuza are banned from doing for a full five years after going straight.

06:30

I made a deposit of 10 million yen. All good.

06:34

Sampei was being ironic. He actually pays in just 1,000 yen.

06:39

Sampei knows first-hand about the struggle to reenter society.

06:51

He left the yakuza and drifted from one job to the next.

06:55

Working for Morohashi has finally brought some stability.

07:04

I always think twice nowadays. I don't want to cause any trouble for Morohashi.

07:19

I rarely get into fights.

07:23

Because if I were to raise my hand, I know I could face jail.

07:31

Morohashi says Sampei is a hard worker.

07:34

Someone who's versatile.

07:36

Always ready to go the extra mile, in more ways than one.

07:46

I don't focus on people's negative points.

07:51

I want to hide any shortcomings by making the most of their positive traits.

07:58

This area used to be so crowded with clubbers.

08:05

Morohashi has faced up to his own turbulent past.

08:12

As a teen, he started abusing stimulants and dropped out of college.

08:17

He had nowhere to go, and fell into the underworld.

08:22

The yakuza group Morohashi joined ostensibly did not deal drugs.

08:27

But he did. And he became an addict.

08:43

I couldn't go five hours without a hit.

08:46

It was like meals.

08:54

I became paranoid, as if I were being followed and targeted.

09:10

I knew the pain would stop if I ditched the drugs.

09:18

But I couldn't.

09:24

Morohashi started hallucinating.

09:26

He was losing his mind.

09:29

Police found him wandering the streets, and placed him under protective custody for a week.

09:35

He was later sent to a psychiatric hospital.

09:38

Morohashi was 28.

09:44

He was even expelled from the yakuza.

09:54

I felt like a total failure.

09:58

I didn't want to start over.

10:09

I actually wanted to take my own life.

10:17

Back then, Morohashi's mother Yoshie still didn't know he had been a gangster.

10:23

His breakdown left her deeply troubled.

10:30

I struggled to breathe. The tears didn't stop.

10:33

It felt like my mouth and nose were covered.

10:37

I couldn't even wash my face for fear of choking.

10:40

I couldn't drink water from a glass, either.

10:45

Morohashi was discharged from hospital, and arrested on suspicion of using stimulants.

10:51

He was given a suspended sentence.

10:59

Morohashi had never sunk so low.

11:02

But the experience was like an epiphany.

11:05

He left the underworld behind, and started searching for an honest line of work.

11:13

I wanted to make my mother happy again.

11:18

I was depressed, but she was worse.

11:22

All because of me.

11:24

I wanted to help her by turning my own life around.

11:35

Reading became a way of life.

11:38

And one book in particular was a great a book source of inspiration.

11:45

It's the autobiography of Ohira Mitsuyo.

11:48

She's a lawyer. And she was once the wife of a yakuza.

11:54

Reading this made me believe I could also rise up from despair.

12:04

That maybe I could make it, too.

12:12

Morohashi decided to become a lawyer.

12:15

Given his background, the challenge could barely have been tougher.

12:19

But after eight years of study, he passed the bar exam.

12:23

And in 2015 - aged 38 - he registered as an attorney.

12:33

The lawyers who mentored Morohashi believe his turbulent history could even be an advantage.

12:43

We have no reason to refuse him, as long as he stays motivated.

12:52

I wish him success all the more because of his past.

12:58

We lawyers must look at how and why our clients committed their crimes,

13:03

and what they will do in the future.

13:10

Not just by listening, but by using the wisdom we've gained through our own lives.

13:16

Imagination and knowledge are vital in criminal defense.

13:28

So Morohashi's first-hand experiences may be an advantage.

13:37

I told him, "You can do it."

13:53

At the same time, other people are skeptical,

13:57

including a close friend who used to be in the same gang as Morohashi.

14:03

He was a yakuza who did many inexplicable things, such as taking stimulants.

14:18

He should now live on the fringes of society.

14:28

I want to say, "Don't get the wrong idea."

14:35

I worry about his role in future.

14:45

But words like that only strengthen Morohashi's motivation.

14:54

Some things hold you back and make you lazy.

15:00

So it's better to shake them off.

15:04

I want to protect the people who come to me for advice. They have suffered, and lived hard lives.

15:31

One person has been confiding in Morohashi more than most.

15:40

He started sending me letters almost every day.

15:46

Authorities suspect the man of fraud during the coronavirus pandemic.

15:55

They believe he unlawfully received kickbacks from government subsidies designed to help struggling businesses.

16:07

They prosecuted him more than 40 times, and kept him in detention for one and a half years.

16:20

The man wrote to Morohashi about his plans to change for the better.

16:28

"I reflect on my crimes."

16:34

"There's someone important for whom I want to start my life again. Someone I want to protect."

16:46

Morohashi regularly visited the man at the police station.

16:50

And he now wants to help him get back on his feet in the outside world.

17:01

"You have an extra desk."

17:03

Yes. I hope he can eventually work here once a week or so.

17:12

A part-time job.

17:18

Morohashi plans to hire the man if he's released on bail.

17:26

Some people really do want to start over.

17:30

And for me, it's rewarding to help.

17:35

It's not so much what I "should" do, but what I "want" to do.

17:41

Hello.

17:45

Morohashi stays in touch with his former clients.

17:49

They include Yanagi Tomonobu.

17:54

He was convicted of possessing and using stimulants eight years ago.

17:58

Morohashi served as his defense attorney.

18:19

Yanagi recalls being surprised,

18:21

because Morohashi didn't look like your garden variety lawyer.

18:28

Unruly types. Takes one to know one.

18:34

I was convinced Morohashi fell into that bracket.

18:42

Yanagi first started taking drugs as a teenager.

18:53

He got clean, and set up a construction company.

18:57

But just as things were going good, his old habit reared its ugly head.

19:07

Yanagi grew dangerously dependent on drugs.

19:10

And he spent little time with his family.

19:13

Eventually, the police took him in.

19:17

Yanagi felt immensely sorry.

19:24

My family cried so much.

19:30

It was devastating.

19:33

Having to meet them with a clear screen between us.

19:37

It was depressing.

19:42

Still, Morohashi didn't tell Yanagi to quit the drugs immediately.

19:50

He said I must not go from black to white all at once.

19:56

Gray is enough to start.

20:00

Society and other lawyers will tell you different.

20:06

They say, "Never ever use drugs." So did the judge at my trial.

20:10

Here you are. Chamomile and peppermint.

20:15

Thanks.

20:18

Yanagi remarried, and set up a food truck two years ago.

20:29

And Morohashi often chips in with advice.

20:40

Spicy and delicious. Just what I wanted.

20:44

I'm so glad. I'll stick it on the menu.

20:54

Thanks.

20:58

Yanagi says he has Morohashi to thank for putting him on the straight and narrow.

21:10

If I got in trouble again and asked him to be my attorney,

21:13

I guess he wouldn't get angry.

21:17

He'd just say, "Again? I understand."

21:21

And that is what prevents me from using drugs.

21:25

He's my deterrent.

21:30

I become friends with my clients.

21:36

I get in touch once a year or so, and ask how they're doing or if they fancy a bite to eat.

21:42

When it comes to avoiding crime, I believe human relationships are crucial.

22:02

The man who kept writing to Morohashi has asked him to be his attorney.

22:06

And Morohashi has accepted.

22:13

Signing the agreement, it's like a vow to protect my client.

22:24

No matter what.

22:28

NHK got in touch with Morohashi's client.

22:32

In a letter, he described him as someone who values honor and kindness.

22:42

But a bombshell came when Morohashi was preparing some documents for court.

22:56

I want to quit.

23:04

I can't believe I have been deceived.

23:10

He discovered that his client was accused of the coronavirus subsidy fraud while on probation for another crime.

23:24

We all have things we don't want to reveal.

23:31

Same goes for my client.

23:38

I guess I have no choice but to do what I can.

23:52

Morohashi offers up some sage advice.

24:00

He really needs to change his way of life.

24:05

He needs to speak more honestly to me and other people.

24:20

I want him to reflect.

24:24

If not, he will be consumed by the fraud case.

24:37

And he won't be able to start over.

24:43

Ultimately, Morohashi decides to carry on defending his client until the court comes to a decision.

25:08

Today, Morohashi is checking up on a former client.

25:12

He wants to see how things are going.

25:19

He too was a yakuza.

25:22

He was trying to collect some money he had loaned to a shop owner,

25:26

when the police arrested him for attempted extortion.

25:34

Morohashi told him to pave the way for a settlement by giving up on the money.

25:40

The case didn't even make it to court.

25:46

Never been to prison. Maybe's God's watching over me.

25:53

Oh, you haven't?

25:57

The man currently earns a living installing solar panels.

26:04

You said I mustn't get involved with gangs.

26:16

It's important that you sever bad ties

26:19

before establishing proper relationships with other people.

26:25

Things are looking up.

26:27

The man plans to hire two people soon for his business.

26:35

Mud sticks for an ex-yakuza like me.

26:42

To be considered a good person, I need to continue doing good deeds like volunteer work.

26:56

- That's great.
- I have to make amends for the past.

27:01

There's no way I can reach Morohashi's level, but I'll follow his lead as much as I can.

27:07

Morohashi has given me so much inspiration.

27:15

And the feeling's mutual.

27:25

It makes me happy to help people start over.

27:30

In fact, they're helping me do just the same.