Protecting Cultural Heritage in Conflict Zones: Shoshana Stewart / President, Turquoise Mountain

Shoshana Stewart is President of Turquoise Mountain, established in 2006, which works to protect heritage and communities at risk around the world.

Transcript

00:03

Direct Talk

00:09

Cultural heritage is often lost
during periods of conflict across the world.

00:14

Centuries old buildings are left to decay.

00:17

Craftsmanship is abandoned.

00:22

But in Afghanistan,
crafts such as

00:24

carpet weaving, pottery,
calligraphy and woodcarving,

00:28

- centuries of craftsmanship
honed on the ancient Silk Road -

00:32

are being preserved
by a cultural heritage charity

00:35

called Turquoise Mountain.

00:37

The charity – founded in Afghanistan -

00:40

was created by King Charles of Britain -

00:42

alongside the then President of Afghanistan,
Hamid Karzai and Rory Stewart.

00:47

It started in 2006

00:50

and the aim is to support local communities

00:53

to generate incomes
through their traditional crafts

00:56

and connect them with international markets.

01:01

In recent years, Turquoise Mountain
have extended their work

01:04

to Myanmar and the Middle East.

01:07

And 95 percent of their staff
come from local communities.

01:11

Direct Talk met with Shoshana Stewart
who has worked for the charity for 17 years,

01:17

and who was appointed their President in 2021.

01:20

Protecting Cultural Heritage in Conflict Zones

01:23

We were created

01:24

with the idea really, of preserving
cultural heritage in Afghanistan,

01:28

because at that point,
30 years of conflict, essentially

01:33

stopped all these traditional crafts
from passing down, destroyed the old city.

01:37

But what we found is that

01:39

with these communities,
particularly artisan communities,

01:42

there was so much more
that needed to be done

01:45

to support them in health care, education,
and particularly in creating incomes.

01:50

Afghanistan is famous

01:53

for a number of things, carpets, of course,

01:55

and it was a huge part of the Silk Road.

01:57

But it is, you know,
a distant history for many people.

02:02

When Shoshana arrived in Kabul in 2006

02:05

to volunteer at Turquoise Mountain,

02:07

it was after a long period
of conflict in the country.

02:11

The ancient buildings of the old town

02:13

were neglected and abandoned,

02:16

rubbish was piled up high in the street,

02:18

and the craftsmen had fled,
as there was no work for them.

02:24

If you walk down the street,
you basically would see,

02:27

you know, one building
would be completely gone.

02:29

So you just have a house sized pile of earth

02:32

and another would have
only one wing left over

02:34

and you would see
the incredible intricate carved woodwork.

02:37

But that's now just exposed to the outside.

02:39

So it was totally derelict.

02:42

No central infrastructure,

02:44

not because it had been destroyed
and it's just never been built.

02:46

So we basically needed to
restore every building

02:49

and try to create basic services.

02:53

Woodwork was possibly the most
important thing when we started,

02:56

both because of
how special Afghan wood work is,

02:58

and they do two different
types styles of carving,

03:01

but also because it was so fundamental
to rebuilding these buildings. So

03:04

finding traditional carpenters
and carvers was hard.

03:07

And

03:08

we met a man named Abdul Hadi,
and he was

03:11

basically Afghanistan's
most famous master woodworker.

03:14

He made this incredible
lattice woodwork jointed,

03:17

and he used to work for the king.

03:19

He was a famous man.
People knew his name.

03:21

But he was in his mid-seventies
and he hadn't produced in 15 years.

03:24

He was selling fruit in the bazaar

03:26

because he had no students and
he had no markets and that's how it stopped.

03:29

So we brought Abdul Hadi out of retirement
and built a school of woodworking around him.

03:34

Over the first five years
of our work in Afghanistan,

03:37

we trained and employed
about 4000 traditional builders,

03:40

that's carpenters, masons, electricians,

03:43

and we restored 150 of
those courtyard buildings.

03:48

To support the communities,
and the families of artisans,

03:51

Turquoise Mountain set up a medical centre,

03:54

primary schools
as well as a training institute

03:57

to teach and pass on
traditional craft skills.

04:02

So we were restoring
these buildings, training artisans.

04:05

But we realized that
no one in this community was going to school.

04:08

No one was going to doctors.

04:09

And so we started
this basic literacy program.

04:12

We started referring to local hospitals,
it grew and grew,

04:15

and now we have a maternal child
health clinic that saw 25,000 patients last year

04:20

and we actually run three primary schools.

04:23

And what we found, especially as Afghanistan

04:27

had such a difficult time
over the last couple of years,

04:30

that actually those frontline services are
some of the most important things we do.

04:34

After the success of their work in Kabul,

04:37

in 2016 Turquoise Mountain extended
its program to rural areas of Afghanistan

04:42

where carpet making
used to be a thriving industry.

04:47

So Afghan carpets actually

04:49

have a reputation around the world,
particularly in the carpet industry.

04:52

And it's for a number of reasons.

04:54

One is that

04:55

sheep in Ghazni, the wool
that comes from those sheep,

04:58

because of the temperature,
is particularly lustrous.

05:00

They produce a lot of lanolin.

05:02

So you have very fine,
very long fibre, very shiny wool.

05:07

So it's special.

05:08

And anyone who makes rugs
around the world knows about this wool.

05:11

But perhaps even more importantly,

05:13

there are close to a million people who
work in the carpet industry in Afghanistan.

05:17

It's massive, and
nearly all of them are women.

05:19

And they know how to weave already.

05:21

So you have a huge group of people
who can earn income

05:24

for their families and who can preserve
these incredible traditions.

05:29

S0 we created about 8000 full time,
full years of employment last year

05:33

in carpet weaving alone for Afghan women.

05:35

And they are able to work and we are able
to export these carpets around the world.

05:41

In the last 17 years,

05:42

Turquoise Mountain has bought back over
$17,000,000 of income back to communities

05:48

by bringing their products
to international markets.

05:52

There has been a growing interest
in artisanship around the world.

05:57

So the good news is that one of the things
that's happened over the last ten years is:

06:01

people are buying increasingly
ethical and sustainable.

06:04

They want to buy something that
they know the name of the person who made it.

06:08

They want to know the story behind it.

06:10

And they will pay a premium for it.
It's a huge growing market.

06:13

It grew through the financial crisis,
grew through COVID.

06:16

The people who are making for that,
are these artisans,

06:19

but they are very far away and they do not
speak the same language and they do not

06:23

obey the same industry standards.

06:25

So we exist

06:27

to connect the world to these artisans
in any way that we need to.

06:32

Oftentimes if you're a business in New York,

06:34

you don't want to transfer
to an Afghan bank account, right?

06:36

So you transfer to us and
then we transfer to the artisan.

06:40

So all of that money goes to
the artisan directly for what they've made

06:45

with the exception of a small percentage,

06:47

which goes to cover our costs of
actually getting that product to market

06:50

and all goes back into the charity.

06:55

Shoshana Stewart grew up in New York.

06:57

She studied Astrophysics at Williams College
and has a MBA from London business school.

07:04

Prior to arriving
in Afghanistan to volunteer,

07:07

Shoshana worked as a teacher
in low-income urban communities

07:11

in New York, Boston and Honduras.

07:16

How I got to Afghanistan as an astrophysicist
and a teacher makes absolutely no sense.

07:22

It's total serendipity.
I was going on an adventure.

07:25

And I was actually volunteering
for this organization,

07:27

which had only been set up
six months earlier.

07:29

This is not a life that I expected at all,

07:32

and I have found myself
loving other cultures.

07:37

I've always had it in my mind

07:38

that you do a job that you like
and you like what it does,

07:41

and I don't think I expected that

07:43

traditional craft in Afghanistan
was my passion in life.

07:48

We did an exhibition at the
Smithsonian Museum in Washington

07:52

and it was essentially a walkthrough
of the old city of Kabul,

07:56

but to do it with an Afghan, in that case

07:59

was a different experience.

08:01

And I was walking with this Afghan man
and he just started crying.

08:05

And,

08:08

because Afghanistan,
in his new home in America,

08:11

to him and anyone who asked him about it,
was about war.

08:14

And he was seeing the Afghanistan and
remembering the Afghanistan that he loved,

08:18

which was fundamentally
about beauty, about landscape.

08:21

And so that's just one example.

08:22

But

08:24

I do think that the moments
that matter to me almost the most

08:28

or the opinions that
matter to me the most are

08:32

often when people from that country,

08:34

but who are in the
diaspora community living outside.

08:38

If I can do something that they're proud of,

08:41

it almost matters to us most.

08:44

In 2016, Turquoise Mountain
decided to work in Myanmar

08:49

- a country which also
has had conflict in its history -

08:52

but which has important heritage and a unique
craftmanship admired around the world.

08:58

Between 2016 and 2020,

09:01

the charity restored the old tourist office
in Yangon, which was at threat of demolition.

09:07

It is a magnificent neo classical building

09:09

dating back to the
beginning of the last century.

09:13

Turquoise Mountain is also generating
an income for the weavers of Myanmar.

09:20

Weaving takes place across Myanmar
and it is hundreds of thousands of people.

09:25

So it is a huge part of the cultural heritage,
but also the economy in Myanmar.

09:30

So the weavers in Myanmar
are from all over the country,

09:34

you know, weaving traditions
all over the country.

09:36

And they are, in all cases,

09:39

the major breadwinner in their family

09:41

or they are one of two people
in their family supporting a huge number.

09:44

And so it is both a case of preserving
the traditions of their community,

09:50

but also providing for them.

09:52

Those weaving traditions are totally unique.

09:54

They weave in patterns,
which is relatively rare.

09:58

You have a lot of hand-woven textiles,
but you often print onto the textiles.

10:04

So the weaving in of the actual patterns
is relatively rare and so distinctive.

10:10

From headquarters in Jordan,
the charity is today helping Syrian artisans

10:15

who fled their country
after the civil war started in 2010.

10:20

Syria has also seen ancient traditions
threatened by an exodus of artisans.

10:27

At first we were looking at
the incredible traditions from Syria

10:31

in the wake of that conflict,
in the midst of that conflict.

10:34

But of course there are
incredible traditions from across the Levant.

10:37

So we now work with Syrians,
Jordanians, Palestinians from Jordan,

10:41

and increasingly expanding.

10:45

If we want to pass this craft on
to the next generation,

10:49

the first thing we must do
is make them love it.

10:53

They need to know it
from a young age.

11:00

As well as helping Palestinian and
other refugees across the Middle East,

11:05

Turquoise Mountain also runs programmes

11:08

to help the children of refugee families
learn about their heritage.

11:13

I think it must be unimaginable, really,

11:16

for those of us
who have not been forced from our homes,

11:18

to think what it would be like not only
to lose the connection to heritage ourselves,

11:22

but to watch our kids
have no natural connection to it

11:25

or their being educated
in a different context.

11:27

And so

11:28

we decided to design these classes,

11:30

which are fundamentally about
the teachers from that community,

11:33

running ten sessions,

11:36

which are about
different elements of that heritage.

11:40

And sometimes it's Syrian heritage
with Syrian communities,

11:42

but sometimes it's broader
Levantine heritage with mixed communities.

11:45

But the reason that we did it,
it's about bringing some joy back to things

11:50

and making the grandparents
and the parents, the authorities.

11:55

It's about the kids coming home and asking

11:57

what their traditional Damascene house
looked like and what are the motifs

12:01

and what are the colours and
what are the food, what are the dances.

12:04

To try to bring a sense of home
and a sense of joy to things.

12:10

Shoshana has encountered many challenges
running programmes in conflict zones,

12:14

particularly when there is regime change.

12:17

In August 2021,
the Taliban took control of Afghanistan.,

12:22

as US forces withdrew
after 20 years in the country.

12:26

And in Myanmar in early 2021,

12:29

the government was overthrown
in a military coup.

12:33

As a result,

12:34

many countries have withdrawn support
for places in which the charity works.

12:42

I think my biggest challenge at the moment,
the thing I worry about is people disengaging

12:47

from difficult places,
from the places I work.

12:50

Because

12:51

we have a difficult relationship with some of
these countries and it can be too hard

12:57

to engage in, because we feel depressed
and hopeless about the situation.

13:03

And so we disengage.

13:06

But actually there's so much more
that can be done than we worry about.

13:10

A huge issue over the last few years
is actually large donor governments

13:15

disengaging from some of these countries

13:19

that are incredibly poor
and incredibly fragile

13:21

and they're just giving much less money.

13:24

And that's partially to do with
governments being more protectionist.

13:28

I actually think
the public is very interested

13:30

in connecting with people
in a difficult place.

13:34

I think actually it's the political
that makes it more difficult.

13:38

Today the work of Turquoise Mountain
can be seen across the world.

13:42

Some of their students
have decorated international hotels,

13:46

and Syrian jewellers in Jordan
have received commissions for fashion shows.

13:50

And earlier this year
King Charles attended an exhibition

13:54

of Turquoise Mountain's work at a museum -
Leighton House in London.

14:00

Ahead lies many challenges in the
current climate of political uncertainty,

14:05

but Shoshana remains determined

14:07

that Turquoise Mountain will continue
to help as many people as they can,

14:11

generate incomes, while also preserving
cultural heritage for future generations.

14:20

Cultural heritage starts from an asset.

14:22

It starts from something that's
fundamentally beautiful about that place

14:27

and something that the world values.

14:28

And I think that

14:29

actually that matters more
in more difficult places

14:32

because it's a fundamentally
respectful relationship.

14:35

It's about what comes naturally
from a community.

14:38

And then you can work on all the things

14:40

that the community is struggling
with alongside it.

14:43

But you have something
fundamentally positive at the heart.

14:52

Beauty connects us all.