Hapi-Line Fukui: Born Alongside the Shinkansen

Hapi-Line Fukui is a parallel conventional line that opened alongside the Hokuriku Shinkansen, running between Kanazawa and Tsuruga. See how the company plans to face its financial challenges.

Hapi-Line Fukui's train running
Shinkansen and parallel conventional line
Hapi-Line Fukui's Fukui Station

Transcript

00:24

Welcome to Japan Railway Journal.

00:26

I'm Miki Clark and today, I will be joining you to bring you the program.

00:31

- Good to see you, Miki.
- Good to see you, too.

00:35

Today's program is all about the third-sector railway in Fukui prefecture, Hapi-Line Fukui.

00:43

Whenever a Shinkansen line opens,

00:46

the conventional line that runs parallel to the Shinkansen will be transferred from the JR to another operator.

00:53

This also happened in March this year when the Hokuriku Shinkansen extension opened.

00:59

And Hapi-Line Fukui was set up to succeed part of the Hokuriku Main Line within Fukui Prefecture.

01:06

Oh that's really interesting. I want to know more about it.

01:12

First, let's take a look at Hapi-Line Fukui.

01:19

On March 16th, the Hokuriku Shinkansen, which connected Tokyo to Kanazawa in Ishikawa Prefecture,

01:27

was extended to Tsuruga in Fukui Prefecture.

01:45

All along the line, opening ceremonies were held at the newly established Shinkansen stations,

01:52

with many people coming to celebrate the opening.

02:04

With the extension, the travel time between Tokyo and Fukui Stations was shortened by up to 36 minutes,

02:12

the shortest time now being just 2 hours and 51 minutes.

02:19

With the introduction of the Shinkansen line, visitor numbers are expected to increase,

02:25

causing an economic ripple effect throughout Fukui Prefecture.

02:32

However, parallel conventional lines have cause for concern.

02:41

That's because parallel conventional lines generally separate from JR when a Shinkansen line opens,

02:49

and become third-sector railways funded by local governments and other entities.

02:56

Tourists traveling from far away and business people commuting to and from work can opt to take the Shinkansen.

03:12

As a result, the parallel conventional line is now primarily used by local residents,

03:18

which will mean a significant decrease in revenue compared to the JR days.

03:31

With the extension of the Hokuriku Shinkansen,

03:34

the section of the Hokuriku Main Line that JR West operated in Fukui Prefecture became "Hapi-Line Fukui."

03:49

The line, which has 18 stations, covers a distance of 84.3 kilometers

03:56

between Daishoji Station, near the prefectural border of Ishikawa Prefecture, and Tsuruga Station.

04:05

All limited express trains that previously connected Osaka and Nagoya in western Japan to Kanazawa

04:12

now terminate at Tsuruga Station, with only local trains operating on the line.

04:22

The new name, "Hapi-Line Fukui," embodies the "happiness" that comes from connecting the various locations along the railway line.

04:37

The night before the JR line officially became Hapi-Line Fukui,

04:42

staff set about replacing all of the station signs at a rapid pace.

04:57

Here we go!

05:01

The rolling stock inherited from JR now features a pink and green stripe along the car body,

05:08

the company's corporate colors.

05:13

There are 16 train sets with 32 cars in total.

05:21

At the time of opening, the company had a total of 280 staff, including approximately 100 full-time employees,

05:29

as well as staff seconded from JR West and temp staff provided by the prefectural government.

05:38

Newly hired employees received training for sales positions and station counter duties.

05:46

Good morning!

05:52

New hires in technical positions received guidance from employees of JR West.

05:58

The plan is to handle all operational tasks entirely in-house within the next ten years.

06:12

Hapi-Line Fukui's president, Mr. Ogawa,

06:16

previously worked as a senior official at the Fukui Prefectural Office, the company's largest shareholder.

06:24

But prior to joining the prefectural office, he worked for Japanese National Railways.

06:29

Considering his background, Mr. Ogawa was the perfect choice to lead Hapi-Line Fukui.

06:36

As a railway company, we have an obligation

06:43

to ensure a safe and stable operation.

06:49

That sense of responsibility makes us more alert and determined.

06:58

This is Fukui Station, the hub for Hapi-Line Fukui.

07:05

In the JR days, the platforms used to accommodate 12-car express trains.

07:11

Now, they only serve local trains with 2 to 4 cars.

07:23

Even so, during rush hour, there are still many passengers, just like there were in the JR days.

07:32

Currently, Hapi-Line Fukui's target is 20,000 passengers per day.

07:44

However, due to inflation, regular fare and commuter pass fees went up 15%

07:51

and student pass fees increased by 5% from what they were in the JR days.

08:01

I'm not thrilled about the fare hike.

08:09

I had to pay around 20 yen extra. I wasn't expecting that.

08:14

Managing the railway is going to be a challenge,

08:18

especially considering the company's incomings and outgoings

08:22

so we decided to raise the fare set by JR by several percentage points.

08:30

This is Tsuruga Station, the terminal station of Hapi-Line Fukui.

08:38

Overseen by JR West, the station also services JR's local trains.

08:47

The Shinkansen station building is located to the east of the conventional line station building.

08:58

On the ground floor, platforms for JR's limited express trains

09:02

coming from the directions of Osaka and Nagoya have been constructed.

09:13

Until recently, passengers could take an express train to Fukui and Kanazawa

09:18

using conventional lines without transferring,

09:22

but with the opening of the Shinkansen, they now have to change at Tsuruga Station.

09:34

Despite the initial inconvenience, Hapi-Line Fukui sees an opportunity to increase its passenger numbers.

09:43

To make transfers easier, moving walkways were installed along the connecting passageway,

09:49

and the timetable was rearranged to make the wait-time between connections 20 minutes or less.

09:57

When people from outside the prefecture visit Fukui,

10:02

they'll see how convenient and efficient our transportation services are.

10:08

Once word gets out, we expect to see even more customers. At least, that's our plan.

10:17

I thought the opening of the shinkansen would be a happy occasion for the area along the line and region,

10:25

but in reality, it seems quite challenging.

10:29

Yes, indeed. Because, the parallel conventional lines would almost always experience decrease ridership,

10:36

and declining in ridership would almost always mean financial difficulties for operators that operate those lines.

10:44

Of course, they are the third sector railway operators,

10:47

so they can expect some subsidies from the public fund,

10:51

but that kind of subsidies are not guaranteed.

10:55

So I think it's almost inevitable for those operators to raise the fares.

11:01

But, regional railways are vital means of transportation for people who can't or wouldn't drive such as students or elderlies.

11:11

So I really hope that they would keep operating stably.

11:16

Yes, in order to realize that stable operation,

11:21

those operators should have good strategies to raise their income, you know.

11:28

Good examples that we can see in many parts of Japan would be to operate tourist trains,

11:35

so that they can boost the number of people coming into the region as tourists.

11:39

And, there should be other possibilities as the strategies.

11:44

Anyway Hapi-Line Fukui should have one or of more of them.

11:47

Yes.

11:49

Next, let's take a look at the strategies Hapi-Line Fukui plans to implement.

11:58

When Hapi-Line Fukui took over the operation,

12:01

they had to pay JR for the station buildings, tracks, and rolling stock.

12:10

Fukui Prefecture negotiated to keep the price of these railway assets as low as possible.

12:24

JR wanted us to buy the operation as a whole, but we first asked to see the fixed asset ledger.

12:31

We checked more that 10 thousand entries to make sure no unnecessary assets were included.

12:38

Initially, JR asked for 10 billion yen but we negotiated that down to 7 billion yen.

12:51

Initially, JR intended to hold on to the commercial facilities inside the station buildings and under the viaducts.

13:00

However, recognizing their value as potential sources of income for Hapi-Line Fukui,

13:05

persistent negotiations eventually led to their acquisition.

13:12

Hapi-Line Fukui's main income stream comes from passenger fares, with an expected annual income of 1.8 billion yen.

13:25

75% of this income comes from commuter and student passes.

13:32

From the moment Hapi-Line Fukui took over the operation,

13:36

it has worked to improve services for its regular passengers.

13:46

Back when JR ran the operation, there was approximately one local train per hour.

13:52

The company now runs two local trains per hour.

14:02

In addition, during the morning and evening rush hours,

14:06

rapid trains were introduced, operating between Fukui and Tsuruga.

14:13

The introduction of rapid trains has reduced the travel time between Fukui and Tsuruga by about 10 minutes.

14:24

With the discontinuation of the limited express trains,

14:27

the number of local trains, 102 when JR controlled the operation,

14:33

has increased to 131, which includes rapid trains.

14:39

It's great! The trains come more often now.

14:43

It's more convenient now.

14:46

Another significant source of income comes from track usage fees paid by JR Freight for the passage of freight trains.

15:00

This line, which is a major logistics route, sees over 30 freight trains daily,

15:07

generating track usage fees of over 1.7 billion yen annually.

15:20

Hapi-Line Fukui aims for an annual revenue of 4 billion yen,

15:25

combining income from passenger sales and track usage fees, among others.

15:35

Despite this, Fukui Prefecture estimates the company will lose approximately 7 billion yen in its first 11 years.

15:43

However, it's prepared to make up the deficit.

15:48

Considering Hapi-Line Fukui's financial situation,

15:52

the prefectural and local governments have created a management fund

15:57

to provide financial aid.

16:03

In light of this, the prefecture and Hapi-Line Fukui are collaborating

16:08

with other third-sector railways to reduce operating costs.

16:15

In Fukui Prefecture, there are two leading third-sector railways.

16:22

Fukui Railway, which operates tram services in and around Fukui City,

16:28

and Echizen Railway, a tourist route in Fukui Prefecture.

16:35

Under the prefecture's guidance, the companies have been collaborating,

16:40

jointly purchasing materials and consolidated contracts for construction projects since the 2020 fiscal year.

16:49

This initiative has already saved the companies approximately 5%,

16:54

compared to if they had made individual purchases and contracts.

17:00

Now, Hapi-Line Fukui is looking to join the initiative as well.

17:06

This agreement will not only help reduce costs but will benefit us in other areas too.

17:13

In case of the natural disasters such as heavy snowfall,

17:20

we can assist each other by lending equipment and vehicles as well as providing services.

17:34

Recently, the three companies released a joint Three Railways Open Ticket,

17:39

which could be used on all three railway lines to celebrate the opening of Hapi-Line Fukui.

17:48

Each line has its own, unique characteristics, so instead of competing,

18:00

we have chosen to work together to better serve the people of Fukui.

18:07

The collaboration seems to be going well, so we intend to keep it up.

18:18

In addition, Hapi-Line Fukui has begun collaborating with third-sector railways across prefectural borders,

18:25

including "IR Ishikawa Railway" in Ishikawa Prefecture and "Ainokaze Toyama Railway" in Toyama Prefecture.

18:38

"IR Ishikawa Railway" took over the section that runs from Kanazawa to Daishoji Station west of Kanazawa

18:46

from JR when the Hokuriku Shinkansen was extended to Fukui Prefecture.

18:52

It's now responsible the approximately 65 kilometer-long train operation.

19:00

Although the operating distance has tripled,

19:02

it's estimated that the company will lose 4.2 billion yen over the next 10 years.

19:15

In response, IR Ishikawa Railway built a new station, which is expected to increase the number of passengers.

19:26

The station is located in a new residential area being developed by Hakusan city.

19:32

The opening of the new Nishi-Matto "park-and-ride" Station was subsidized by the local government and city.

19:45

It doesn't take as long to get to school now, so I can sleep in a little longer.

19:53

It's very convenient.

19:57

Together, IR Ishikawa Railway and Hapi-Line Fukui now operate 44 daily through-services between Fukui and Kanazawa.

20:19

We have been cooperating with the neighboring Ainokaze Toyama Railway.

20:27

We look forward to working with Hapi-Line Fukui in the same way.

20:36

We are now operating through-services and we plan to offer discounts for transfers between railways.

20:48

We also have plans for various promotions.

20:57

With Ainokaze Toyama Railway, Hapi-Line Fukui and IR Ishikawa Railway are working together to attract tourists,

21:06

which include plans to run Ainokaze Toyama Railway's popular tourist train "The Story of 13000'" in all three prefectures.

21:19

Because the prefecture was instrumental in creating the third-sector railway

21:24

some might consider us a burden, but we've never thought that way.

21:37

We have been given a valuable asset that we plan to use

21:44

to provide services that benefit the public. If we think positively, I believe we can do just that.

21:56

As the president of Hapi-Line Fukui said,

21:59

it's important to consider the line as a good asset but not a burden

22:03

and use it for the benefit of the local community, and I thought this was a good way of thinking.

22:09

One thing I should point out here is that that section of the railway Hapi-Line Fukui operates is

22:16

still a very vital link for the entire narrow gauge network of Japan, which the country of Japan cannot afford to lose.

22:24

Having said that, now Hapi-Line Fukui is owned by the people of Fukui,

22:29

which means the company can and should make their line a better serve the local community.

22:37

For example, opening a couple of new stations or running faster, bigger or more frequent trains

22:47

would be among the future possibilities for improvements.

22:50

It truly is a railway for the local people.

22:55

Next up is Tourist Trains in Style, where we introduce amazing tourist trains from all across Japan.

23:14

"Nagara" is a tourist train operated by the third-sector "Nagaragawa Railway" in Gifu Prefecture.

23:23

It runs from Mino-Ota Station, a transfer station for the JR Takayama Line, to Gujo-Hachiman Station,

23:31

covering approximately 47 kilometers in about an hour and a half.

23:42

The Royal Red two-car train stands out against the scenic landscape along the line.

23:57

The interior design is resplendent in wood sourced from Gifu Prefecture, creating a warm atmosphere.

24:07

In addition, local traditional crafts are adorned throughout,

24:11

allowing passengers to experience the region's history and culture.

24:21

There is a range of seating options available, from four-person seats to counter seats,

24:27

catering to both groups and solo travelers.

24:34

In Car 1, curtains separating the seats and the aisle create a compartment-like ambiance.

24:48

There is also a variety of tour plans, including a meal plan and a sweets plan.

24:58

Today, we are taking the "Lunch Course."

25:06

At 10:45 am, the train departs Mino-Ota Station.

25:14

The two attendants in each car are responsible for serving meals

25:18

and providing tourist information about the area along the line.

25:27

The lunch course features a creative menu devised by a chef from a local hotel.

25:37

It's filled with a variety of dishes made from local ingredients such as Hida beef and locally farmed chicken.

25:50

The train travels along the picturesque Nagara River,

26:03

slowing down as it approaches scenic spots along the way.

26:25

At Oya Station, a passing station on the single track line,

26:30

the train makes a 15-minute stop while waiting for a train to pass.

26:35

The passengers freely enjoy this time, with some taking photos by the lead car.

26:49

Finally, the train approaches its final destination, Gujo-Hachiman Station.

26:58

With its scenic views and delicious cuisine, this railway journey is one to cherish.

27:13

The wood made it feel warm and cozy.

27:18

It was fun and the food was great.

27:21

We need to take it easy now and then.

27:25

The tourist train "Nagara" operates mainly on Fridays, weekends, and holidays, making one round trip per day.